The Report · data-driven NFL insights, delivered every morning

Week 4 recap

Week leader: Kalm with +57.8. Season leader: baba with +410.8.
Best forecaster this week: Elo, +79.0 on 16 games, 11 right.
Biggest upset: NE won at 29% (NE 29, BUF 26).
Biggest crowd miss: NE at BUF, the crowd (3 players) had BUF at 66%.
Best single pick: Presser had MIN at 90% for +24.0.

Our picks

Bold call of the week: LV. Missed (KC 30, LV 27, Elo +1.0).
Lock of the week: BAL. Hit (TEN 18, BAL 24, Elo +21.0).

Season: locks 5–4, bold calls 1–8. Full record.

Model scoreboard

Every forecaster scored as a player on its closing numbers, this week and season to date.

#ForecasterGamesRightThis weekSeason
1Elo1611/16+79.0+518.4
2The System169/16+65.2+588.8
3The blend169/16+65.0+615.2
4Kalshi169/16+54.4+495.7
5Polymarket169/16+52.7+500.3
6Sportsbooks169/16+48.2+479.2
7Closing spread169/16+38.5+535.4

How the spots played

Every game

GameScoreEloMarketBlendSpotElo ptsMarket pts
PIT at CLE
wind 9 mph, 78°F (heat hurts favorites)
CLE PIT 24, CLE 27CLE 52%PIT 58%PIT 56%Big disagreement+2.0-8.6
IND at WSH
wind 6 mph, 68°F
IND IND 30, WSH 13IND 64%IND 66%IND 68%Tight agreement+12.0+13.4
NYJ at CHI
wind 7 mph, 66°F
CHI NYJ 12, CHI 23CHI 62%CHI 63%CHI 65%Tight agreement+10.6+11.3
ARI at NYG
wind 5 mph, 63°F
NYG ARI 24, NYG 36NYG 54%ARI 56%ARI 53%Everything else+3.8-6.4
LAR at PHI
wind 6 mph, 63°F
LAR LAR 24, PHI 20PHI 54%LAR 63%LAR 59%Big disagreement-4.2+11.3
GB at TB
wind 4 mph, 87°F (heat hurts favorites)
GB GB 17, TB 14GB 66%GB 59%GB 61%Everything else+13.4+8.2
TEN at BAL
wind 6 mph, 62°F
BAL TEN 18, BAL 24BAL 80%BAL 85%BAL 84%Clear favorite, mild disagreement+21.0+22.8
DAL at HOUDAL DAL 34, HOU 30HOU 61%HOU 58%HOU 61%Tight agreement-12.2-8.6
NE at BUF
wind 11 mph, 67°F
NE NE 29, BUF 26BUF 65%BUF 74%BUF 71%Clear favorite, mild disagreement-17.2-29.8
JAX at CIN
wind 3 mph, 72°F
JAX JAX 22, CIN 17CIN 51%CIN 56%CIN 55%Everything else-1.0-6.4
MIA at MINMIN MIA 10, MIN 15MIN 81%MIN 82%MIN 84%Tight agreement+21.4+21.8
LAC at SEA
wind 4 mph, 62°F
SEA LAC 23, SEA 30SEA 79%SEA 75%SEA 78%Tight agreement+20.6+18.8
KC at LVKC KC 30, LV 27KC 51%KC 67%KC 63%Big disagreement+1.0+14.1
DEN at SF
wind 4 mph, 87°F (heat hurts favorites)
SF DEN 14, SF 24SF 61%SF 59%SF 61%Tight agreement+9.8+8.2
DET at CAR
wind 1 mph, 65°F
CAR DET 26, CAR 32DET 52%DET 66%DET 62%Big disagreement-2.0-18.6
ATL at NOATL ATL 45, NO 24ATL 50%NO 52%NO 51%Coin flips+0.0-2.0

Elo movers

Up
  • ATL +31 → 1493
  • IND +28 → 1504
  • NYG +23 → 1495
  • DAL +20 → 1483
  • CAR +20 → 1485
Down
  • NO -31 → 1451
  • WSH -28 → 1428
  • ARI -23 → 1438
  • HOU -20 → 1489
  • DET -20 → 1511

Players this week

#PlayerGamesPoints
1Elo (the model)16+79.0
2Pure Elo (baba)16+79.0
3Bold (baba)16+79.0
4Maybe (Kalm)16+70.7
5Presser bot · baba16+68.1
6Strong (baba)16+65.9
7The System16+65.2
8The blend16+65.0
9Fader bot · Kalm16+64.3
10QB1 bot · Kalm16+59.9
11Scout bot · baba16+59.9
12Claudious bot · baba16+58.9
13The bot crowd16+58.4
14Cautious (baba)16+57.9
15Kalm16+57.8
16The crowd16+55.1
17Kalshi16+54.4
18Exchange bot · Kalm16+54.4
19The sharp crowd16+53.7
20Polymarket16+52.7
21Homer bot · Kalm16+52.6
22Mendo16+51.4
23Marketeer bot · baba16+50.6
24Pure market (baba)16+49.5
25Sportsbooks16+48.2
26baba16+46.7
27Contrarian bot · Kalm16+39.0
28Closing spread16+38.5

4 players on the season board. Full leaderboard.

Want this by email when a week finishes? Turn it on in your profile. Next week's numbers are on Predictions.